The place for all things wine, focused on serious wine discussions.

TN: Musigny 1989-2000; other Burgundies with food

Moderators: Jenise, Robin Garr, David M. Bueker

no avatar
User

Max Hauser

Rank

Ultra geek

Posts

447

Joined

Thu Jul 19, 2007 2:57 pm

Location

Usually western US

TN: Musigny 1989-2000; other Burgundies with food

by Max Hauser » Thu Aug 23, 2007 1:23 pm

Through auspices of a venerable gastronomic organization, with honored guests from Canada and elsewhere, local wine geeks tasted Musignys, then dined in the usual format, "en Paulée" (B. Y. O. Burgundy). The company was good, and bottles people brought were surprising and deliciously paired with dishes the restaurant* made for the purpose.

Tasted blind: Le Musigny of Georges de Vogüé (Vieilles-Vignes) 1989, 90, 91, 95, 99; Louis Jadot 1990; Joseph Drouhin 1999; Jacques-Frédéric Mugnier 2000. (All bought two years ago, for this tasting.)

Tasting highlights. Musigny is sometimes called the most elegant and balanced of red Burgundies: wines anyone would enjoy a lot, with or without experience. Always special-occasion wines (and figuring in some of my own peak wine experiences for 20-plus years), Musignys shot up radically in price lately. Breezy references to "the Moose" are seen on US wine-critic Web sites.** Clear favorite of the 28 blind tasters was the 2000 Mugnier (which he himself "actually preferred to his 99s, calling them 'wines of pleasure.' ") Mugnier is a gracious gentleman, by the way, and serious about his wines, always in limited supply. Bright fruit acid and anise in the aroma, deep and rich. Exquisite concentrated Pinot fruit, and truffly elements. This one I didn't spit, which is rare. The 99 Drouhin and 90 Jadot were next favorites, leaving the five de Vogüés, the 90 being least popular (dark, dense, tannic, enjoyable but less opulent than most) -- matching some earlier critical assessment of this wine in a generally excellent vintage.

Dinner Wines. People at our table brought great whites. 88 Bachelet-Ramonet Bienvenue-Bâtard-Montrachet, 98 Bâtard-Montrachet from same producer, 2000 Dom. du Chateau de Puligny-Montrachet Chevalier-Montrachet. All concentrated, nutty, mineraled; I especially enjoyed BBM and 2000 CM which was passed around to other tables to share the experience. (With rouget with braised endive, greens, fennel, pear tomatoes.) With a crispy duck confit on wild rice cake and spinach we tried young reds. 00 Groffier Chamb.-Mus. "Amoureuses" was sadly, though barely, corked. My 98 Denis Mortet Clos de Vougeot, bought on release, was showing well, richer on the palate than the nose, concentrated, cherryish. With roasted lamb-loin slices and on to a well-chosen cheese plate we tried 83 Bruno Clair-Daü Bonnes-Mares, 2000 Frédéric Esmonin Clos de Vougeot (outstanding!), 78 LaBouré-Roi Grands-Échézeaux (aging well) and random bottles I can't remember, mostly very good, proffered by other tables as we passed things around. Good wines, good company, lively discussion incl. novel etymology of Échézeaux -- one diner (Burgundy buyer for a well-known wine dealer) described the French dissertation-book written about the lieus-dits of Burgundy -- kept in his car for emergency reference.


* 231 Ellsworth in San Mateo, California -- coincidentally also the longtime home of Morrison Wood.

** That breezy nickname evidently coincides with the price increase. I saw the phrase "the moose" for Musigny tossed off on the Parker forum, but had seen it in none of the major Burgundy books nor heard anyone use it ten years ago. Also, 10-15 years ago, though well known to Burgundy fans, these wines were far cheaper. (In early 1990s I found de Vogüé Musignys at restaurants below $100, inconceivable today.) Quick search disclosed "the moose" first used for Musigny on major wine newsgroups only in 2005 (by Dale Williams in fact); on WLDG originally for other meanings than Musigny; never on Chowhound's wine forum; and on Squires, first in July 2000 by Allen Meadows, the respected US Burgundy writer.
no avatar
User

Dale Williams

Rank

Compassionate Connoisseur

Posts

11125

Joined

Tue Mar 21, 2006 4:32 pm

Location

Dobbs Ferry, NY (NYC metro)

Re: TN: Musigny 1989-2000; other Burgundies with food

by Dale Williams » Thu Aug 23, 2007 2:25 pm

Thanks for notes. I have not had the 2000 Mugnier Musigny, but thought the Amoureuses and village were great.

As to the breezy references, I'm scarcely in the vanguard. Don't know how you searched, but a quick look show Alan (I think that's Weinberg) certainly had references to "Moose" on WLDG in a post on a Bipin D. tasting in 1999. And Jim Jones before I ever did on AFW. I can only see my one use of "moose" in print, but I might be more likely to say it in conversation (once subject is established), as I do Zind, Cos, Batard,Beze, etc. Less syllables the better is my motto. :)

In any case my consumption of Musigny, never significant, will basically screech to a halt unless others are kind to me. The only Musigny I ever actually purchased was the 2001 Mugnier, split with two others at about $45 each, which was great (if infanticide). But I've been blessed with tasting quite a few Mugniers, a couple Drouhins, and the '97 Roumier. But with current pricing I think that is a thing of the past, I don't have that many rich friends. And think the Mugnier Amoureuses and Bonne Mares are also out of my reach, at least in "good" vintages. Luckily, I like the vllage Chambolle (and the new NSG).
no avatar
User

Mark Lipton

Rank

Oenochemist

Posts

4285

Joined

Wed Mar 22, 2006 1:18 pm

Location

Indiana

Re: TN: Musigny 1989-2000; other Burgundies with food

by Mark Lipton » Thu Aug 23, 2007 2:52 pm

Thanks for the interesting notes, Max. As for the provenance of the breezy Moose term, I personally blame Joe Perry for that and other crimes against the French language. (He may not really bear the blame, but he's an excellent scapegoat nonetheless and currently less than likely to issue a rebuttal [he's on honeymoon in Piemonte])

Mark Lipton
no avatar
User

Dan Donahue

Rank

Ultra geek

Posts

359

Joined

Thu Mar 23, 2006 5:02 pm

Location

IL

Re: TN: Musigny 1989-2000; other Burgundies with food

by Dan Donahue » Thu Aug 23, 2007 4:40 pm

Max, a special time indeed.

Dale, d'accord. The run up in Burg pricing is scary. Many of the '05s that I grabbed 6 or 7 months ago on pre-arrival are now priced outside of my comfort zone. I do have some of the Mugnier CM's and Marechales--04s and '05s--tucked away. Have you tired any of the NSGs?
Je ne peux pas le faire

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Amazonbot, ClaudeBot and 2 guests

Powered by phpBB ® | phpBB3 Style by KomiDesign