Everything about food, from matching food and wine to recipes, techniques and trends.

Cake vs. Pie

Moderators: Jenise, Robin Garr, David M. Bueker

no avatar
User

Daisy D

Rank

Wine geek

Posts

85

Joined

Mon Nov 07, 2011 10:43 pm

Location

PVB, FL

Cake vs. Pie

by Daisy D » Tue Oct 09, 2012 7:54 pm

When thinking about how I enjoy my time in the kitchen, it usually comes when I'm baking. Mainly because my brain does better with exact measurements than it does with throwing things in a pot and hoping it all works out. Having had a sweet tooth for as long as I can remember I'm always excited by the dessert course, but now enjoy when they have more of a savory element to them. We dined at a local cafe this past Friday and my eyes widened as I gazed upon the well lit confectionary case. On our way home we started the debate what makes the better sweet end to a meal: cake or pie? How does one compare things that can be so different? As my husband pointed out, I would have to make the comparisons as equitable as possible: from 'point of sale origin' to cost of treat.

I can't compare a standard quarter sheet cake from the grocery chain to a scratch made pie from the local bakery that's been around for 25 years with a strong following. Comparing the grocery store basics - vanilla birthday cake vs. apple pie - cake would win more often than not for me; really only because I'm not a HUGE fan of apple pie. French silk pie is a different story. At the local cafe, however, that makes all their pastries on site comparisons are a little harder to do. Pie would win in this case. The buttery crust of a warm piece of apple pie that flakes apart and melts in your mouth upon hitting your tongue would beat out the large slice of vanilla cake.

Going back & forth, while one may (eventually) win more times than the other, both cake and pie would have a fair showing in this fight. In choosing one victor in the battle, I would have to choose pie. While cake comes in many varieties, the options for pie (at least as they appear to me at the moment) seem to be far more varied; the options for different crusts & fillings and their subsequent combinations would provide much more room for experimentation of flavors and palate satisfaction.
...Eating is the only form of professionalism most people ever attain. - Don Delillo
no avatar
User

Jenise

Rank

FLDG Dishwasher

Posts

42547

Joined

Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:45 pm

Location

The Pacific Northest Westest

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Jenise » Tue Oct 09, 2012 8:09 pm

I'm suddenly reminded of a friend who worked for a womens magazine telling me about a survey they did for a story, asking women in some mall or similar public situation what they would rather have, cake or sex? One woman responded by asking, "regular sex or vacation sex?" Caught by surprise, the reporter suggested they make it vacation sex, to which the woman then said, "Okay, so what flavor cake?"

Lacking your sweet tooth, I would have to say that I find most commercially made desserts overly sweet, and I don't like frostings, custards or cream fillings or toppings. Taking all that off the table, not much is left except fruit pies. So, pie for me.
My wine shopping and I have never had a problem. Just a perpetual race between the bankruptcy court and Hell.--Rogov
no avatar
User

Fred Sipe

Rank

Ultra geek

Posts

444

Joined

Thu Jul 13, 2006 11:34 am

Location

Sunless Rust-Belt NE Ohio

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Fred Sipe » Tue Oct 09, 2012 8:14 pm

I may, or may not, be an anomaly. I'm just not much of a sweets eater of any kind except for a few bites of my "medicinal" dark chocolate with my morning coffee. When it comes to dessert, just give me another glass of wine.

But on the occasions when I do have dessert, when it's cake it's cheesecake, or one of those chocolatey liquid center things. When it's pie, it's usually not fruit, more like graham cracker cream or pecan.

After a really fine meal for the sake of the meal, I look forward to a really good cup of coffee and something sweet Tarte tatin is nice even though I'm not much for fruit pies.
no avatar
User

Daisy D

Rank

Wine geek

Posts

85

Joined

Mon Nov 07, 2011 10:43 pm

Location

PVB, FL

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Daisy D » Tue Oct 09, 2012 8:22 pm

Fred Sipe wrote:After a really fine meal for the sake of the meal, I look forward to a really good cup of coffee and something sweet Tarte tatin is nice even though I'm not much for fruit pies.


Much agreed with the good cup of coffee after an excellent meal.
...Eating is the only form of professionalism most people ever attain. - Don Delillo
no avatar
User

Carrie L.

Rank

Golfball Gourmet

Posts

2476

Joined

Thu Oct 12, 2006 8:12 am

Location

Extreme Southwest & Extreme Northeast

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Carrie L. » Tue Oct 09, 2012 8:27 pm

Jenise wrote:I'm suddenly reminded of a friend who worked for a womens magazine telling me about a survey they did for a story, asking women in some mall or similar public situation what they would rather have, cake or sex? One woman responded by asking, "regular sex or vacation sex?" Caught by surprise, the reporter suggested they make it vacation sex, to which the woman then said, "Okay, so what flavor cake?"


That made me laugh!
Hello. My name is Carrie, and I...I....still like oaked Chardonnay. (Please don't judge.)
no avatar
User

Carrie L.

Rank

Golfball Gourmet

Posts

2476

Joined

Thu Oct 12, 2006 8:12 am

Location

Extreme Southwest & Extreme Northeast

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Carrie L. » Tue Oct 09, 2012 8:38 pm

Daisy, I agree. A lot of variables come into play. Is it fresh, is it ala mode, is it French Silk? With cake, I've been disappointed a lot in restaurants. Too dry, too dense, too rich, too sweet, too something. Like Fred, I do like the lava cakes but sometimes those can be too runny! I'm not crazy about apple pie either, unless it's super fresh, with Macintosh apples and not too much cinnamon, and a rich buttery crust. Oh and make it warm with vanilla ice cream. I am a huge blueberry pie fan and haven't had too many disappointments there, so I would say pie.
Hello. My name is Carrie, and I...I....still like oaked Chardonnay. (Please don't judge.)
no avatar
User

Howie Hart

Rank

The Hart of Buffalo

Posts

6389

Joined

Thu Mar 23, 2006 4:13 pm

Location

Niagara Falls, NY

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Howie Hart » Wed Oct 10, 2012 8:10 am

When I was young, I had dinner at my girl friend's house. She had 4 sisters. Her paternal grandmother, who had 5 sons, was also at the dinner. The grandmother told me, flat out, "Girls like cake, boys like pie". I've always preferred pie, as do my 5 sons.
Chico - Hey! This Bottle is empty!
Groucho - That's because it's dry Champagne.
no avatar
User

David M. Bueker

Rank

Riesling Guru

Posts

34251

Joined

Thu Mar 23, 2006 11:52 am

Location

Connecticut

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by David M. Bueker » Wed Oct 10, 2012 8:44 am

Cake - chcoclate cake with cream cheese frosting to be precise.

Unless it's my grandmother's apple pie.
Decisions are made by those who show up
no avatar
User

Rahsaan

Rank

Wild and Crazy Guy

Posts

9216

Joined

Tue Mar 28, 2006 8:20 pm

Location

New York, NY

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Rahsaan » Wed Oct 10, 2012 10:04 am

If the question is what to eat after a meal, lighter is always better so I would have to say pie. Or even better, a custard of some sort.

However if the question is which confection is more interesting, I would have to say cake, as they can get more complex and display more of the baker's skill. However increasingly I find that these cakes are best enjoyed in the afternoon, as a snack. Which is of course the custom in Germany, with my wife's family, where they never eat confections after dinner but rather in the afternoon with coffee.
no avatar
User

Hoke

Rank

Achieving Wine Immortality

Posts

11420

Joined

Sat Apr 15, 2006 1:07 am

Location

Portland, OR

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Hoke » Wed Oct 10, 2012 11:17 am

Jenise wrote:I'm suddenly reminded of a friend who worked for a womens magazine telling me about a survey they did for a story, asking women in some mall or similar public situation what they would rather have, cake or sex? One woman responded by asking, "regular sex or vacation sex?" Caught by surprise, the reporter suggested they make it vacation sex, to which the woman then said, "Okay, so what flavor cake?"

Lacking your sweet tooth, I would have to say that I find most commercially made desserts overly sweet, and I don't like frostings, custards or cream fillings or toppings. Taking all that off the table, not much is left except fruit pies. So, pie for me.


Okay, what flavor pie?

And instead of vacation sex? :)
no avatar
User

Shaji M

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

669

Joined

Thu Apr 05, 2007 3:24 pm

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Shaji M » Wed Oct 10, 2012 11:35 am

Once I was on this vacation..I mean pie..thats what I meant..pie..definitely pie..sometimes cake..you got me all confused now! Thanks Jenise
no avatar
User

Mark Lipton

Rank

Oenochemist

Posts

4285

Joined

Wed Mar 22, 2006 1:18 pm

Location

Indiana

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Mark Lipton » Wed Oct 10, 2012 11:36 am

Not much of a dessert fancier, either, but on those rare occasions when I do have a dessert it'll be a slice of pie or tart rather than cake. Fruit pies are preferred and overly sweet versions are disparaged. All in all, though, I'd rather eat cheese! :mrgreen:

Mark Lipton
no avatar
User

Karen/NoCA

Rank

Hunter/Gatherer

Posts

6325

Joined

Thu Mar 23, 2006 8:55 pm

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Karen/NoCA » Wed Oct 10, 2012 11:42 am

Cake? Nope, too dense, too sweet. Now pie is another story. It must be home made. My favorite is coconut cream pie made by a dear friend. My other favorite is a pear pie made by our next door neighbor who has died but the men in the family make a few for us when their pear tree has a good year. The men also make the best apple pies for us when their apple tree has a good year. I am not a baker, but I do keep breakfast muffins and cookies in the freezer for Gene. On occasion, I have made a few things, a family recipe for Sherry Cream Pie is a favorite, and is over 70 years old. Some sort of a lemon thing made by a fireman in San Francisco is wonderful, and I enjoy making that. When our lemon tree gives us lemons, I make a lot of lemon bars for us and our neighbors...they are very good. When I started putting lemon zest into the crust, they got even better. :)
no avatar
User

Daisy D

Rank

Wine geek

Posts

85

Joined

Mon Nov 07, 2011 10:43 pm

Location

PVB, FL

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Daisy D » Wed Oct 10, 2012 11:48 am

Mark Lipton wrote:All in all, though, I'd rather eat cheese! :mrgreen:


You & my husband would get along swimmingly.
...Eating is the only form of professionalism most people ever attain. - Don Delillo
no avatar
User

Shaji M

Rank

Wine guru

Posts

669

Joined

Thu Apr 05, 2007 3:24 pm

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Shaji M » Wed Oct 10, 2012 1:33 pm

Karen/NoCA wrote: When our lemon tree gives us lemons, I make a lot of lemon bars for us and our neighbors...they are very good. When I started putting lemon zest into the crust, they got even better. :)

Lemon bars are one of those that can be a cake or a pie. I like lemon bars. I will happily eat it while vacationing :twisted:
no avatar
User

Mike Filigenzi

Rank

Known for his fashionable hair

Posts

8187

Joined

Mon Mar 20, 2006 4:43 pm

Location

Sacramento, CA

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Mike Filigenzi » Thu Oct 11, 2012 12:19 am

Funny, but I really have to think about this one. First off, I'm not a big fan of fruit pies. I like them but they don't really excite me. There's a caramel-pine nut-rosemary tart that my wife makes that's the kind of thing I REALLY like, and that would certainly be more of a pie than a cake.

For me, a cake has to be of very high quality before it matches a good tart (and there's a lot of bad cake out there). A good cake has to be moist, well-flavored, and the frosting has to match it well. I tend to prefer a denser, three-plus layer cake over a lighter one with just a couple of layers. Frosting has to be first-rate buttercream, Italian meringue, or maybe a cream cheese version. All aspects of the cake have to be well-made and they have to work well together but when that happens, I find that superior to pretty much any pie.

But not to vacation sex.
"People who love to eat are always the best people"

- Julia Child
no avatar
User

Jo Ann Henderson

Rank

Mealtime Maven

Posts

3920

Joined

Fri Feb 16, 2007 9:34 am

Location

Seattle, WA USA

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Jo Ann Henderson » Thu Oct 11, 2012 7:50 pm

Is it a vacation with my husband? Does tart fit into the pie category? I need a bit more clarity. :?
"...To undersalt deliberately in the name of dietary chic is to omit from the music of cookery the indispensable bass line over which all tastes and smells form their harmonies." -- Robert Farrar Capon
no avatar
User

Jenise

Rank

FLDG Dishwasher

Posts

42547

Joined

Tue Mar 21, 2006 2:45 pm

Location

The Pacific Northest Westest

Re: Cake vs. Pie

by Jenise » Fri Oct 12, 2012 12:01 pm

Jo Ann Henderson wrote:Is it a vacation with my husband? Does tart fit into the pie category? I need a bit more clarity. :?


What flavor tart? :D
My wine shopping and I have never had a problem. Just a perpetual race between the bankruptcy court and Hell.--Rogov

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests

Powered by phpBB ® | phpBB3 Style by KomiDesign