The place for all things wine, focused on serious wine discussions.
User avatar

Robin Garr


Forum Janitor




Fri Feb 17, 2006 2:44 pm


Louisville, KY

WTN /WineAdvisor: Pinot versus Pinot (Jadot 04 Brgne, Saintsbury 05 Garnet)

by Robin Garr » Mon Feb 12, 2007 4:08 pm

Pinot versus Pinot

In Burgundy, they've been growing and making great wine from Pinot Noir grapes for at least 500 years, a heritage that clearly has not been lost on vine growers and wine makers around the world.

But Pinot Noir is a notoriously tricky grape, and as recently as 20 years or so ago, wine writers - including me - would routinely dismiss New World Pinot as a riddle, an enigma that California and other places would love to solve if only they could.

What a difference a couple of decades makes!

Long before the movie <I>Sideways</I> turned Pinot Noir into a household name, producers in Oregon, and California's cooler valleys - not to mention similar ventures in New Zealand, here and there in Australia and beyond - were learning more and more about the climates, soils and clonal selections that would foster excellent Pinot.

And if much of the new wave of Pinot didn't exactly resemble Burgundy in its character and style, there's not really anything wrong with that, particularly from the point of view of wine lovers who value variety over conformity, as long as the wine is good.

Now that <I>Sideways</i>-inspired marketing has turned "Pinot Noir" into the modern equivalent of "a glass of red wine," some high-end New World bottlings are approaching the price levels of all but the most ethereal Burgundies. Sadly, some industrial producers are producing cheap, forgettable and barely varietally identifiable Pinot all over the world, too.

But how about the relatively affordable mid-range? In price ranges that most serious wine enthusiasts will at least consider for everyday enjoyment, how do New World Pinots stack up against the Old? To find out, I compared-and-contrasted two established labels from large but respected producers in France and California: <b>Louis Jadot</b> of Beaune in Burgundy, and <b>Saintsbury</b> of Carneros, the cool, bayside wine region that straddles the southern end of both Napa and Sonoma.

I didn't open them side-by-side in a "blind" tasting, choosing instead to enjoy them in a more informal setting as wine with dinner, sampling them on separate nights in fairly close proximity and taking careful notes in order to compare.

Viewed in that light, I would rank both wines quite closely for both quality and value. The Burgundy, as you might expect, showed a bit more earthy minerality and tannic structure; the California wine held to its regional model with a bit more forward fruit and softer, but still ample, acidity. I enjoyed both wines very much, and while I'd like to seem them both selling closer to the low teens in an ideal world, had no complaints about either. I'd drink 'em again.

<table border="0" align="right" width="170"><tr><td><img src="" border="1" align="right"></td></tr></table>Louis Jadot 2004 Bourgogne Pinot Noir ($17.99)

Dark garnet with a clear edge. Fresh bing cherries, clean if simple fruit, gains depth from a stony mineral backdrop that's impressive for a relatively modest Bourgogne. Crisp acidity and soft but perceptible tannins provide balance. U.S. importer: Kobrand Corp, NYC. (Feb. 11, 2007)

<B>FOOD MATCH:</b> A simple but credible Burgundy, it makes a fine pairing with a simple winter dinner, vegetable soup made with fresh veggies, beef shank meat and a strong beef stock.

<B>VALUE:</B> The rising price of Burgundies, and wines priced in Euros in general, takes its toll on a wine that once sold for $10 or below, but it's certainly competitive at this price in 2007. Note also that individual merchants quote widely variable prices for this label, so shop around.

<B>WHEN TO DRINK:</B> Meant for short-term enjoyment, but excellent balance and perceptible tannins suggest that it wouldn't suffer from a few years under good cellar conditions.

The Louis Jadot Website is published in French and English. Choose the French or British flag for the language you prefer:

For Jadot's distributors in six continents, click "Distributors" from the Home Page.
Look up vendors and compare prices for Louis Jadot Bourgogne Pinot Noir on

<table border="0" align="right" width="170"><tr><td><img src="" border="1" align="right"></td></tr></table>Saintsbury 2005 "Garnet" Carneros Pinot Noir ($17.99)

Ruby, clear and rather light, typical of cool-climate Pinot. Subtle but pleasant red-cherry aromas; crisp and fresh flavor, bright fruit and zippy acidity. Excellent food wine. It holds its own in this "shootout" against a comparably priced Bourgogne Pinot Noir: It's a little more fruity, a little more extracted, but pure flavors and good acidic balance serve it well. (Feb. 2, 2007)

<B>FOOD MATCH:</b> This Pinot shows its food-friendly nature, making a beautiful match in a red-wine-with-fish pairing, ahi tuna seared sushi-rare with garlic, ginger and a soy-lime marinade.

<B>VALUE:</B> I remember with nostlgia when Saintsbury Garnet was a great value at $10 or less, but that's not going to happen with a quality California Pinot in the age of <I>Sideways</i>. Even so, it justifies a high-teens price with quality.

<B>WHEN TO DRINK:</B> Although it's not a wine made for aging (Saintsbury fans enjoy it while waiting for the winery's "Carneros" bottling to mature), its balance and fruit will hold it for a reasonable term on the wine rack. Pinot is unpredictable in the cellar, but gamblers might give it a try.

The Saintsbury Website offers an article and fact sheet about Garnet Pinot Noir here:

Look up vendors and compare prices for Saintsbury Garnet on

<center>Subscribe to The 30 Second Wine Advisor</center>

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests

Powered by phpBB ® | phpBB3 Style by KomiDesign