Thanks for posting the notes Salil.
I was less enthusiatic about the
'97 Pichler than you (makes sense as I am less enthusiastic about everything than you), finding it oddly reminiscent of Sauvignon Blanc with a very grassy finish. It did seem very young though.
The
Trimbach VT was outstanding, though for the first few sips I was wondering if it was really Trimbach. It actually gave too much. Then the finishing lemon washed steel kicked in on the finish & everything was right with the world.
The
Wendouree was fabulous. I think it will hang on for a long time based on its balance. I was surprised at the drinkability, though by the end of the night it resembled a Thin Mint Girl Scout cookie more than anything else.
The
Vieille Julienne was as you described it - zin like and rather simple. I have a few '03 Chateauneufs, but not many. I am glad with that status.
The
Clos Mogador was even better than I would have expected. So many berries in that wine that it would make good bear bait.
I really liked both Bordeaux. I think the
Clerc Milon is better now, as it's slightly more developed. The
Pichon Baron seems like it will indeed be delicious for years to come. The Clerc Milon did have a rather wet/loose cork, so not all bottles may have reached such a nice place this early.
Loved the
Coteaux du Layon SGN, as it had very little VA (something that always bothers me in older botrytis wine). I could have drank a lot more of it if I did not need to stay in good condition.
Anyway, fun night. Hope to do it again soon.