by Dale Williams » Wed Sep 17, 2025 4:17 pm
Nice group at Balvanera Tuesday for a look at 1990 Bordeaux. We started with bacalau croquettas, octopus, chorizo iberico, and salad
2015 Billecart-Salmon “le Rose” Champagne
Apparently they put the 2015 Elisabeth into this. Strawberry and maraschino, citrus pith, a bit of bread. Fun, B+
2018 Agrapart “Avizoise” Champagne Extra Brut
Granny smith, lemon pie, citrus zest and a hint of hazelnut. Fresh, long and complex. A-
2021 Francois et Fils "Veauvignere" Condrieu
Decent acids for viognier, ripe peach, honeysucklely floral notes. Not really my thing but drinkable. B-
1990 Ch. Laville Haut Brion
Fig and pear, oak, stony, not showing much after opening. Liked much more at end of night, much more integrated oak, some citrus to fill out the sweeter fruits. B- PnP, B+ with air
For the reds we ordered a bunch of skirt steaks,morcilla, carrots, fries, and mashed potatoes
1990 Ch. Angelus
Ripe but not roasted, black raspberry chocolate bar, some cedary notes, light vanilla. B+/A-
1990 Ch. Lagrange
Cassis, coffee, green tobacco leaf, I quite enjoyed, some found thin (they were wrong). B+
1990 Ch Leoville Barton
Cassis, leather, cedar, some green herb, there’s a little more roughness to the tannins than the other wines. B
1990 Ch. Pape Clement
Black cherry, anise, tobacco, cigarbox, not big but with good drive and an exotic edge. A-/B+
1990 Ch. La Fleur de Gay.
Black plum, licorice, an exotic note of gamebird, soft acidity. B+
1990 Ch. L'Evangile
Lush black fruits, mocha, truffles, a little sandalwood. Very long. A-/A
1990 Ch. Leoville Las Cases
Apparently a pretty saturated cork and some felt not representative. Slightly dull cassis fruit, cigar ash, some oaky notes, fairly hard tannins. B
1990 Ch. Leoville Poyferre
Great showing, cassis and black cherry, tobacco, and an almost Californian eucalyptus note. Smoky mineral finish, long. A-
Somewhere in here we ordered some lamb sausage (turned out to be rather spicy)
1990 Ch. Sociando-Mallet
Black currant, green pepper, green herbs, it’s Sociando alright! And a good one. B+/A-
1990 Ch. .Lynch Bages
Lovely exotic nose with dark fruits and incense, on the palate cassis and kirsch with a cocoa overtone, just a hint of roasted. B+/B
1994 Warre Port (375)
Surprisingly ready, blackberry and blueberry with licorice and candied orange, tangy finish. B+
There were an assortment of desserts, but I don’t eat and left for my train. Fun night with a great group, and Balvanera’s food was delicious (as usual).
Group voting
L'Evangile 21pts
Poyferre 10
Angelus 9
Lynch Bages 6
Pape Clement 2
48 pts total- Congratulations to all for counting to 6 correctly!
Grade disclaimer: I'm a very easy grader, basically A is an excellent wine, B a good wine, C drinkable. Anything below C means I wouldn't drink at a party where it was only choice. Furthermore, I offer no promises of objectivity, accuracy, and certainly not of consistency.